
I’ve asked myself this question on countless occasions. Am I a terrible person for eating meat? Or as most animal rights supporters will say, “How can you support animal rights and eat meat if it causes animal suffering?” I understand their point as I have come to ask myself the same thing, but a lot of the times I feel conflicted about whether eating meat contradicts what I support.
I once visited a forum and read a comment that was posted by a vegan, in which she compared eating meat to murder. And although, I can see where she’s coming from, I just can’t shake the feeling that the comparison seemed to be a pretty unfair analogy. Murder is associated with spiteful and evil intentions, whereas when people eat meat, it’s not like they’re doing it out of spite or hate. I doubt many of the people that eat meat take pleasure in killing or seeing an animal die.
Is the act of eating meat not a part of the circle of life, of the order of the food chain that makes this world and every being on it function in a sustainable structure? Hypothetically speaking, if animals were able to engage in complex reasoning like humans, would we expect them to not eat meat either? What I’m getting at is this, why is the actual, particular act of eating meat thought to be so evil? Is it not natural? Which reminds me of a memorable quote:
“Of all the animals, man is the only one that is cruel. He is the only one that inflicts pain for the pleasure of doing it.” –Mark Twain
According to Twain’s quote, “cruel” is being associated with one who “inflicts pain for the pleasure of doing it,” so then is it still cruel to eat meat, because eating meat doesn’t necessarily inflict pain to animals for the pleasure of doing it. If we consider the slaughterhouses or factory farms that don’t treat or kill the animals in a humane way, I do agree that it would be very cruel, and I wouldn’t support places like that. For that reason, why not go for organic meat where the animals are raised more naturally in open spaces and where the farms abide by humane treatment standards of animals as set forth by the Humane Society of the United States or Humane Society International.

This blog isn’t meant to challenge any vegan or vegetarian on their personal lifestyle, but it is for me and anyone else out there that also feels torn between their love for animals and their meat-eating lifestyle. I think eating meat is natural, but I think what slaughterhouse establishments do to their animals while raising them is sickeningly unnatural (i.e. force-feeding of ducks and geese to swell up their livers up to ten times their normal size for the sale of “foie gras” or immobilizing calves to tiny boxes before killing for the sale of veal). This type of treatment I cannot support, and I will not even eat any of those so-called “delicacies” because of how that treatment is totally unnatural, repulsively cruel, and incredibly inhumane. Because of this treatment in slaughterhouses, many people refrain from eating meat because they don’t want to support that kind of cruelty. However, I don’t think the act of eating meat itself is synonymous with the cruelty of those slaughterhouses.
My logical side of my mind says that there are ways to eat meat and be a humane person too, but my heart fights with taking a life for food when it’s not the last resort. For the question of being a terrible person if you eat meat, I say that no one should be judged for eating meat. Although, I do admit that I’m barely hanging on to this meat-eating lifestyle…
Suggested Related Links:
Ethical Food Revolution Picks Up Pace With 62% Rise
Should We Eat Meat?
Why Animal Rights?
WashingtonPost.com - For Meat-Eating Authors, A More Tender Approach
Gawker - Vegans
Ban Foie Gras - How You Can Help